Technologies · Ceres

Ceres Ice Train

coilguns on Ceres throw blocks of ice a second toward Venus, each , until of water is on its way: enough for a global ocean. Each Brick leaves at , falls toward the Sun for and is caught by the Braking Ring. Launches run from to .

Every number is marked:Physics: Measured, or established physicsPrecedent: Demonstrated in the real world, citedInvented: A breakthrough the plan assumesDesign choice: A size, count or date the plan choosesSelect any number to see how it is computed.

Ceres Ice Train orbits, to scaleTo scale. Bricks fall from Ceres's orbit at 2.77 AU to Venus's at 0.723 AU along half an ellipse, in 1.15 yr. Throwing the ice stretches Ceres's orbit to an aphelion of 3.29 AU.Ceres's orbit after the campaign: 2.77 AU at its nearest, 3.29 AU at its farthestCeres's orbit, 2.77 AU (treated as a circle)Venus's orbit, 0.723 AUA later window, 8.5 months after the one beforeA later window, 8.5 months after the one beforeHohmann transfer: 1.15 yr from Ceres to VenusBricks fallBricks fallfor 1.15 yrfor 1.15 yrThe SunSunCeres at launch, 2.77 AU from the SunCeresat launchVenus when the Brick leavesVenusVenusat launchat launchVenus when the Brick arrives, 1.15 yr laterVenusat arrivalCeres's new aphelion, 3.29 AUNew aphelion3.29 AUVenus 0.723 AUCeres 2.77 AUVenus's orbitCeres's orbit, beforeCeres's orbit, afterBrick transferLater windowsThe fall1.15 yr, half the ellipselaunched at 6.4 km/sarrives 9.08 km/s faster than VenusLaunch windowscheapest every 8.5 monthsabout 3.3 in the campaign,June 2033 to October 2035Ceres pays in orbitrecoil adds 0.76 km/s to its speedaphelion moves out to 3.29 AU(today's real aphelion: 2.98 AU)Orbits to scale; dots enlargedSeen from the north: everythinggoes round anticlockwise.
The Ice Train's orbits. Bricks fall from Ceres to Venus along half an ellipse in 1.15 yr; the cheapest windows come every 8.5 months. Throwing the ice backward pushes Ceres forward, stretching its orbit out to 3.29 AU.View sourceSVG
The data in words

To scale, seen from the north. Venus orbits at 0.723 AU, Ceres at 2.77 AU. A Brick thrown backward from Ceres falls along a Hohmann transfer ellipse that touches both orbits, arriving 1.15 yr later, 9.08 km/s faster than Venus. Each later window turns the whole picture by the angle Ceres moves in 8.5 months. The recoil leaves Ceres on an ellipse from 2.77 AU to 3.29 AU.

QuantityValue
Venus's orbit0.723 AU
Ceres's orbit (as a circle)2.77 AU
Transfer time1.15 yr
Muzzle speed6.4 km/s
Arrival speed relative to Venus, far out9.08 km/s
Time between cheap windows8.5 months
Windows in the campaign3.3
Launch campaignJune 2033 to October 2035
Speed Ceres gains0.76 km/s
Ceres's new aphelion3.29 AU
Ceres's real aphelion today2.98 AU

Principle

Ceres is the easiest large store of water to leave in the inner Solar System. Its density suggests it is up to water by mass, and its gravity is feeble: at the surface, an escape speed of .

Falling to Venus

Ceres circles the Sun at , Venus at . Ice thrown backward along Ceres's orbit, against Ceres's motion, is left moving too slowly to stay at Ceres's distance. It falls inward along half an ellipse whose far end touches Ceres's orbit and whose near end touches Venus's. This is a Hohmann transfer, the cheapest path between two circular orbits. The kick is relative to Ceres; with the climb out of Ceres's own gravity, the muzzle speed is . The fall takes half the ellipse's period: .

On the way in, the Sun's gravity speeds the ice up. It reaches Venus's orbit moving faster than Venus itself, by , and overtakes the planet from behind. Venus's gravity then pulls it in: at the Ring's height it is moving at .

Launch windows

A Brick arrives at Venus's orbit after it leaves, and Venus must be there to meet it. That needs the two planets at the right angle at launch, an alignment that comes round once every synodic period, : about windows in the campaign.

The Railheads fire all the time anyway, because the Lattice's power is steady and the deadline is fixed. Shots between windows need faster orbits, timed to meet Venus, and they cost more energy. The model prices every shot at the Hohmann minimum and does not yet compute the off-window penalty. Faster arrivals also bring more energy for the Ring to recover, which offsets part of the cost after the first catch; before it, the Lattice pays.

Energy per kilogram

A Railhead turns electricity into motion at , so each kilogram launched draws , half of which leaves with the ice as motion. One Brick carries and draws . Launching all the water takes , the largest single item in the energy budget, and the Railheads together draw .

Why the Ring gets back more than the Railheads spend

The Braking Ring recovers of electricity from each kilogram it catches: times the the Railhead drew to launch it. Nothing is free here. The ice falls from Ceres's orbit down the Sun's gravity well to Venus's, then into Venus's own well. Between launch and catch, gravity adds to its motion, more than the Railheads put in. Neither well alone would be enough: the Sun's gives the arrival speed, Venus's pull to the Ring's height adds the rest.

That surplus is why the Ice Train runs on its own catch from . How the energy gets back to Ceres is in the Ring's energy loop.

Ceres pays in orbit

Throwing of Ceres's mass backward pushes Ceres forward, the way a gun recoils. Summed over the campaign its speed rises by . The model treats Ceres's slightly oval orbit (it already swings out to ) as a circle at its average distance, and the push as a single kick. On those terms the circle becomes an ellipse, still from the Sun at its nearest and at its farthest. Spread over the campaign, about half of Ceres's year, the same push raises Ceres's average distance by about as much but leaves the orbit rounder. Either way Ceres moves away from Earth, never toward it, and the change is permanent.

Design

Railheads

Each Railhead is a coilgun long that accelerates a Brick at to in , then fires again later on average. It draws and stores energy between shots, so the power in the barrel during a shot is higher still.

Every shot kicks the Railhead back as hard as it pushes the Brick forward. The coilguns are anchored in Ceres's rock, which takes the recoil; summed over a hundred billion Bricks, that recoil is what moves Ceres's orbit. Ceres also spins, so a Railhead fixed in its rock points the right way only part of the time. The Railheads are spread around Ceres and steered so that some always face backward along its orbit; the model's firing interval is an average over all of them.

Ice Bricks

A Brick is of ice, a cube on a side, wrapped in a reflective graphite-fibre sock that keeps sunlight off it as it falls toward the Sun, so it arrives near . Under a bare Brick would carry at its back face, many times what cold ice can bear. It rides in a sabot that supports it along its whole length; the sabot stays at the muzzle and is reused. The Brick itself carries nothing but a laser retroreflector.

Steering

Across the inner Solar System and more than a year of flight, the smallest aiming error at the muzzle grows into a miss of many kilometres. Lattice lasers track each Brick by its retroreflector and steer it by ablation: a pulse boils a little ice off one face and the vapour pushes the Brick the other way. Each Brick must meet its catcher track at the Ring's height, on time, on the side of Venus it was assigned (see catching).

Power

Until the first catch the Helios Lattice beams the Railheads their . Even at the plan's longest beam range, , a beam focuses to . Receiving that much power is a design problem of its own. At the Lattice's receiver intensity of , the receivers would need more area than Ceres's whole surface, so they must fly in space around Ceres and send power down by cable, or run at higher intensity. The model sizes the Lattice's receivers in total, not Ceres's share.

From the Ring's recovered electricity powers Venus's systems, so the Lattice's beams can stay on Ceres. In energy terms the Ice Train then pays for itself.

How much water

is of Earth's water and of Ceres's, if Ceres is water. That is the top of the published range. At the low end the same ocean would take most of Ceres's water, and comets from the outer belt become the fallback.

Specifications

ParameterValue
Water shipped, of Ceres's water
Campaign to ()
Throughput, Bricks a second
Railheads, each firing every
Railhead long, , in
Brick, a cube on a side
Energy per shot ( drawn at )
Power in all, each
Transfer; arrives at relative to Venus
Launch windowsEvery , about in the campaign
Ceres's recoil; its aphelion moves to

What is invented

Build sequence

  • : The Railhead experiment must throw ice from a coilgun on Earth by the end of the year. Its pass and kill marks are on the Research Agenda; a kill signal stops this line of work.
  • : The Lattice reaches full power and the first Bricks leave Ceres. The Railheads, their receivers and the Brick works must be finished by now. The model does not yet schedule their construction on Ceres or count their mass: an open gap.
  • : The first Bricks reach Venus and the Ring starts catching. From now the Ring's electricity powers Venus and the Lattice's beams stay on Ceres.
  • : The last Bricks leave. Ice launched later could not arrive and be lowered before the deadline.
  • : The last Bricks reach the Ring, before the deadline.

Failure modes and safeguards

  • A Brick misses its track. Every approach skims the Ring's height, above the air, so a missed Brick swings past Venus instead of hitting it. It goes back into solar orbit, where Lattice lasers can steer it for a later return.
  • A Brick breaks up at launch. The pieces follow the same transfer orbit to the same catch, so the Ring must handle rubble as well as whole Bricks.
  • The Foundry runs slow. The first launch waits for the Lattice's full power, so every day the Foundry loses comes straight out of the campaign. The Railheads must then fire harder, or less water arrives.
  • Railheads fail. independent coilguns degrade gracefully: losing some lowers the rate, not the whole campaign.
  • Ceres has less water than assumed. The ocean then takes a larger share of Ceres's water; comets from the outer belt are the fallback.
  • Ceres's orbit. The change is permanent and needs international agreement before the first shot. The model does not yet check the new orbit's long-term stability against Jupiter's pull.
  • Weapons. A coilgun that can hit a track at Venus can hit anything. The safeguards are open telemetry, inspection and treaty oversight (Risks and Governance).

Reproduce these numbers

The Ice Train's numbers come from calc/src/model/ice.ts; the energy gravity adds is in calc/src/model/budget.ts and the catch in calc/src/model/ring.ts.

pnpm calc --only ice-departure-dv       # the Hohmann kick from Ceres
pnpm calc --only launch-energy-per-kg   # electricity drawn per kilogram launched
pnpm calc --only ice-solar-gain         # what gravity adds between launch and catch
pnpm calc --only ceres-new-aphelion     # Ceres's new orbit

In the Explorer, lower the water shipped (ice-mass): the ocean gets shallower, Ceres's recoil and the Railheads' power fall with it, and so does the Ring's catch. Move Ceres's water share (ceres-water-fraction) to the low end of its range and the same ocean takes most of Ceres's water. Slow the Foundry (foundry-doubling-days): launches start later and the campaign shortens. A few days more per doubling is enough to push the simulated Earth-like date past the deadline.