Technologies · Near Venus

Braking Ring

A orbital ring above Venus catches every Brick the Ice Train throws. Its sleds brake each one from to orbital speed and turn the motion into electricity instead of heat: over the campaign, at the full catch rate. Catching works. Lowering the caught ice to the surface on tethers, as designed, does not yet: it is the plan's open problem.

Every number is marked:Physics: Measured, or established physicsPrecedent: Demonstrated in the real world, citedInvented: A breakthrough the plan assumesDesign choice: A size, count or date the plan choosesSelect any number to see how it is computed.

Braking Ring: catching the Ice TrainLeft, to scale, seen from the north: Venus and the Ring 400 km up. Bricks come from behind Venus at 9.08 km/s, half aimed past each side, and Venus's gravity bends them onto the Ring's height at 13.5 km/s, eastbound on one side, westbound on the other. Right, a side view along the Ring: a catch, the parking belt and a tether lift.Seen from the northTo scale; tracks and belt enlargedVenusturns slowly westwardBraking Ring: 400 km up, 6,452 km from Venus's centreEastbound Bricks: 9.08 km/s far out, 13.5 km/s at the RingWestbound Bricks: 9.08 km/s far out, 13.5 km/s at the RingEastbound catch at 13.5 km/sWestbound catch at 13.5 km/sEastbound catchEastbound catchbraked to 7.1 km/sbraked to 7.1 km/sWestbound catchWestbound catchthe mirror imagethe mirror imageArrows: each catch pushes its track the way itsArrows: each catch pushes its track the way itsBrick was going. The twists cancel; the pushes add.Brick was going. The twists cancel; the pushes add.!Open problemOpen problemthe forward pushes add up tothe forward pushes add up to270 times the Ring's lift270 times the Ring's liftNet push on the Ring: 8.1 × 10¹⁵ N, along Venus's orbital motionnet push8.1 × 10¹⁵ NBraking RingBraking Ring400 km up; dotted: parking belt400 km up; dotted: parking beltBricks arrive from behind Venus,Bricks arrive from behind Venus,9.08 km/s faster than the planet;9.08 km/s faster than the planet;its gravity bends them ontoits gravity bends them ontothe Ring's height at 13.5 km/sthe Ring's height at 13.5 km/sVenus'sorbitalmotionto the Sun0 km100 km200 km300 km400 kmSide view along the RingHeights to scale, lengths notair; clouds up to 70 kmThe Ring at 400 km: a rotor at 10 km/s inside a stator that stands stillrotor 10 km/s inside a still statorin at 13.5 km/strack 140 km, 50 gparking belt3,000 tether liftsa Brick every 1.4 sdown to 100 kmreleased, fallsgaining 0.87 MJ/kg!Open problemOpen problemlowering needslowering needs150 times the Ring's lift150 times the Ring's liftIce BrickRingTracks, tethers
How the Braking Ring catches the ice. Every Brick comes from behind Venus and is bent onto the Ring's height, caught eastbound or westbound at 13.5 km/s. The two catches' twists cancel but their forward pushes add to 8.1 × 10¹⁵ N, 270 times the Ring's lift, and lowering the ice on tethers needs 150 times: both are open problems.View sourceSVG
The data in words

Seen from the north and to scale, the Ring circles Venus 400 km up. Bricks arrive from behind Venus 9.08 km/s faster than the planet; Venus's gravity bends each stream onto the Ring's height, where catcher tracks 140 km long brake them at 50 g from 13.5 km/s to 7.1 km/s and release them into a parking belt. Each catch pushes its track the way its Brick was going: the twists cancel, but the pushes add to 8.1 × 10¹⁵ N forward, 270 times the Ring's lift, an open problem. In a side view, 3,000 tether lifts were to lower a Brick every 1.4 s to 100 km, an open problem: it needs 150 times the Ring's lift.

QuantityValue
Ring altitude400 km
Ring radius from Venus's centre6,452 km
Arrival speed far out9.08 km/s
Speed at the Ring13.5 km/s
Orbital speed at the Ring7.1 km/s
Rotor speed10 km/s
Catcher track140 km at 50 g
Tether lifts3,000, a Brick every 1.4 s
Release height100 km
Energy gained in the fall0.87 MJ/kg
Net braking push on the Ring8.1 × 10¹⁵ N
Net push over the Ring's lift270
Lowering force over the Ring's lift150

Principle

How an orbital ring stands up

At the Ring's height, gravity is . Anything moving there at is in orbit: gravity bends its path into a circle exactly. The Ring's rotor, a loop of , runs faster, at . Moving that fast it would fly outward if nothing held it down. The stator holds it: a ring of tracks, tethers and receivers, , that rides on the rotor through magnetic bearings. The rotor presses up on the stator and the stator's weight holds the rotor down. Nothing in the stator orbits, so its tracks and tethers can stand still over Venus without rockets. Venus turns so slowly that standing still over the ground and standing still in space are nearly the same thing.

After carrying the stator, the rotor has of lift to spare, enough to hold hanging at rest. That one number decides what the Ring can do and what it cannot.

Catching

Every Brick arrives from the same direction, overtaking Venus from behind along its orbit (see falling to Venus). Aimed to pass one side of the planet or the other, it skims the Ring's height going one way round or the other. A sled on a catcher track about long takes it at , brakes it at to orbital speed and releases it into a parking belt beside the Ring. The belt has two lanes, because eastbound and westbound Bricks end up orbiting in opposite directions and must never share one. The sled's linear motor runs as a generator, so the braking makes electricity.

Each kilogram gives up of motion. At the Ring recovers as electricity. The rest heats the tracks and is radiated to space from above the air, never into it.

Braking pushes on the tracks along the Ring with at the full rate, far more than the rotor's of lift. Version 2 caught half the Bricks eastbound and half westbound so the two pushes would cancel. They cancel the twist on the Ring, not the force. Every Brick arrives from the same direction, and the two streams graze the Ring at mirror-image points, each turned half its path's bend away from that direction (the path's eccentricity is ). Their sideways pushes cancel; their forward pushes add, to along Venus's orbital motion, times the rotor's lift. An orbital ring has no stiff way to hand an in-plane force to the planet, so the model's ring-net-force check fails until a design does (issue #3).

The energy loop

The Ring recovers , more than the the Railheads draw on Ceres. The model checks this on every run (the ring-energy-loop check in calc/src/model/ring.ts). The surplus is not free: it is gravity's work on the falling ice, , explained in the Ice Train.

Energy flows of the Phosphoros campaign, to the deadlineSunlight 5.2 × 10²⁸ J reaches the Lattice; it delivers 7.8 × 10²⁷ J. The Ring recovers 5.3 × 10²⁷ J from the falling ice and pays the Railheads back. The Exhaust throws 4.1 × 10²⁷ J into space as light.Sunlight and electricityMotion of the iceVenus's heat, and light to spaceWaste heatSunlight on the Lattice's film: 5.2 × 10²⁸ JWaste heat from the film, lasers and receivers: 4.4 × 10²⁸ JWarming 3.8 × 10²⁵ J, oxygen 2.7 × 10²⁵ J, hardware 10²² JLattice to the Railheads, before the first catch: 2.0 × 10²⁷ JLattice energy left over: 2.2 × 10²⁷ JHeat-pump work: 3.5 × 10²⁷ JRing to the Railheads: 2.1 × 10²⁷ JMotion the Railheads give the ice: 2.0 × 10²⁷ JWaste heat at the Railheads: 2.0 × 10²⁷ JEnergy gravity adds to the falling ice: 4.6 × 10²⁷ JRing energy left over: 3.2 × 10²⁷ JWaste heat at the Ring: 1.3 × 10²⁷ JHeat lifted from Venus's air: 6.0 × 10²⁶ JLight thrown into space: 4.1 × 10²⁷ JHelios Lattice: 7.8 × 10²⁷ J deliveredCeres Railheads: 4.1 × 10²⁷ JBraking Ring: 6.6 × 10²⁷ J caughtGravity: 4.6 × 10²⁷ JPhotonic Exhaust: 4.1 × 10²⁷ JVenus's heat: 6.0 × 10²⁶ JRing's surplusLattice's spareLight to space: 4.1 × 10²⁷ JThe Ring powers the Railheads: 2.1 × 10²⁷ JThe Ring powers the Railheads: 2.1 × 10²⁷ JCeres RailheadsCeres RailheadsBraking RingBraking RingWaste heatWaste heat2.0 × 10²⁷ J2.0 × 10²⁷ JGravity of the SunGravity of the Sunand of Venusand of Venus4.6 × 10²⁷ J4.6 × 10²⁷ JWaste heatWaste heat1.3 × 10²⁷ J1.3 × 10²⁷ JRing's surplusRing's surplus3.2 × 10²⁷ J3.2 × 10²⁷ JLattice's spareLattice's spare2.2 × 10²⁷ J2.2 × 10²⁷ JPhotonic ExhaustPhotonic ExhaustLight to spaceLight to space4.1 × 10²⁷ J4.1 × 10²⁷ JVenus's heatVenus's heat6.0 × 10²⁶ J6.0 × 10²⁶ JThe air's own heat, plus heat that leaks inThe air's own heat, plus heat that leaks infrom the crust, the Forges, the falling icefrom the crust, the Forges, the falling iceand the sunlight the Veil lets throughand the sunlight the Veil lets throughHelios LatticeHelios Lattice7.8 × 10²⁷ J delivered7.8 × 10²⁷ J deliveredSunlight5.2 × 10²⁸ JWaste heatfilm, lasers, receivers4.4 × 10²⁸ JWarming, oxygen, hardwareWarming, oxygen, hardware3.8 × 10²⁵ J, 2.7 × 10²⁵ J, 10²² J3.8 × 10²⁵ J, 2.7 × 10²⁵ J, 10²² J
Where the energy goes. Of 5.2 × 10²⁸ J of sunlight on its film, the Lattice delivers 7.8 × 10²⁷ J, 15%. The Braking Ring recovers 5.3 × 10²⁷ J from the falling ice, mostly energy gravity gave it, and pays the Railheads back. The Exhaust throws Venus's heat and its own work into space as light. The two spares come to 42% of all supply.View sourceSVG
The data in words

Energy over the campaign, to the deadline. At every node the flows in equal the flows out; a flow too small to see is drawn one pixel wide.

FromToEnergy
The SunHelios Lattice5.2 × 10²⁸ J
Helios LatticeWaste heat (film, lasers, receivers)4.4 × 10²⁸ J
Helios LatticeCeres Railheads, until the first catch2.0 × 10²⁷ J
Helios LatticePhotonic Exhaust (heat-pump work)3.5 × 10²⁷ J
Helios LatticeWarming the air and melting the last ice3.8 × 10²⁵ J
Helios LatticeForging the oxygen2.7 × 10²⁵ J
Helios LatticeBuilding the hardware10²² J
Helios LatticeSpare2.2 × 10²⁷ J
Braking RingCeres Railheads, after the first catch2.1 × 10²⁷ J
Ceres RailheadsMotion of the ice2.0 × 10²⁷ J
Ceres RailheadsWaste heat2.0 × 10²⁷ J
Gravity of the Sun and VenusMotion of the ice4.6 × 10²⁷ J
Motion of the iceBraking Ring6.6 × 10²⁷ J
Braking RingWaste heat1.3 × 10²⁷ J
Braking RingSpare3.2 × 10²⁷ J
Venus's airPhotonic Exhaust (heat lifted)6.0 × 10²⁶ J
Photonic ExhaustLight to space4.1 × 10²⁷ J

The loop closes by swapping customers, not by a second beam. Beaming the Ring's electricity to Ceres would lose half of it in the lasers () and a quarter of the rest in the receivers (). Instead the Ring's power runs down the tethers to Venus's own systems, and the Helios Lattice, which already beams to Ceres, keeps doing so. The day-by-day simulation counts it exactly this way: from , Venus gets the Lattice's power plus the Ring's, less what the Railheads take.

Why the ice must not simply fall

Ice falling freely from Ceres would hit Venus at and bring of heat. That is times all the heat the Photonic Exhaust spends years pumping out of the air (), and more than the Lattice delivers in the whole campaign (). Braking in the air is the same disaster, slower: aerobraking turns motion into heat in the atmosphere. The Ring takes the motion out above the air, as electricity.

Design

Structure

The Ring circles Venus's equator from the planet's centre and weighs in all. The rotor is built in segments joined at controlled breakpoints, so a failure sheds a segment rather than unzipping the loop. The stator carries the catcher tracks, the Lattice's receivers and the tether heads.

The power hub

The Lattice's beams arrive at receivers on the stator at . Their loss heat, , radiates to space from fins at , above the air. Superconducting cables carry the power, the Lattice's and the Ring's own, down the tethers to the Exhaust canopies above the clouds. Until the Ring is complete, receivers on the canopies carry the load and the Exhaust removes their loss heat.

Catcher tracks

Braking at would load a bare Brick with , more than cold ice can bear, so each sled cradles its Brick along its whole length, as the sabot did at launch. At the full rate the tracks hold thousands of Bricks at once, so the Ring carries many tracks side by side around its circumference.

Parking

A Brick released at orbital speed from the Ring would come back round to the point where it left, once every orbit. So each parked Brick gets a small second push, by laser ablation as in flight, to lift its orbit clear of the Ring. By the time lowering was to start, most of a year's catch is circling in the belt.

Lowering, as designed

From to , tether lifts were to take parked Bricks, slow them to rest, and lower them to , each lift handling a Brick every . Released there, a Brick falls the rest of the way and gains , close to the needed to melt it and warm the water to Earth's temperature. Slowing parked ice to rest would also recover more electricity, which the energy budget never counted.

Lowering: the open problem

This does not work. Bringing ice to rest far below the Ring means taking back all the downward momentum gravity gives it on the way. Even if each Brick fell freely and stopped at the bottom in an instant, the tethers would have to take back the momentum of that fall. At that is a force of at least . The rotor has to spare: times too little. The model's ring-lowering-load check fails, on purpose, until this is solved.

Three options are under study, and none is free.

  1. Drop the Bricks from rest at the Ring. The tethers are not needed, but each kilogram then lands with instead of : of extra heat, close to half the heat in the whole atmosphere (). It arrives while the air is cold, when pumping heat out costs most. In the model this pushes the Earth-like date past the deadline unless the Exhaust grows substantially, and then the budget closes only with the Ring's energy. Stopping a parked Brick also leans its weight on the Ring as it slows below orbital speed, so each stop must be brief.
  2. Lower more slowly. The force falls in proportion to the rate. Closing the gap this way takes times as long as the plan allows: centuries, not months.
  3. A far heavier or faster rotor. Lift grows with the rotor's mass and with how far its speed exceeds orbital speed. Closing the gap by mass alone needs a rotor heavier than all the machinery the Foundry ever builds (); by speed alone, a rotor many times faster, storing many times the energy.

A mix of the three may do better than any one. Meanwhile the energy budget still closes, because it never counted the lowering's recovered energy. The simulation does assume the tethers work: the heat it counts from the falling ice is the fall from .

Specifications

ParameterValue
Altitude and circumference,
Rotor speed (orbital speed )
Mass (rotor , stator )
Catcher tracksAbout long, braking at
Brick arrival
Energy recovered of motion, as electricity
Recovered power at full rate
Braking force; east and west catches cancel the twist, not the force
Without the RingIce would hit at and dump of heat, times the air's
Tether lifts, each lowering a Brick every

What is invented

Build sequence

  • : Construction begins, from parts the Ouroboros Foundry ships from Mercury.
  • : The Foundry's growing output now covers the Ring's whole mass.
  • : The Ring is complete and takes the Lattice's receivers from the canopies.
  • : The first Bricks arrive and the Ring starts catching. From now its electricity powers Venus's systems.
  • : Lowering was to begin. It waits on the open problem; until then the catch stays parked.
  • : The last Bricks are caught.

Failure modes and safeguards

  • A Brick misses its track. Every approach skims the Ring's height, above the air, so a missed Brick swings past Venus and back into solar orbit, where Lattice lasers can steer it for a later return.
  • The catch falls out of balance. If eastbound catching stops, westbound catching stops with it. The two directions are scheduled together so the twist on the Ring always cancels. The forward push does not, which is the open problem above.
  • The rotor fails. Controlled breakpoints shed one segment rather than the loop.
  • A crowded parking belt. Every parked Brick carries a retroreflector and is tracked; nudges keep the belt clear of the Ring and the two opposite-running lanes clear of each other, where a collision would come at twice orbital speed.
  • Lowering stays unsolved. The ice stays parked while the options are worked. Dropping it from the Ring remains possible, at the cost in heat and time described above.
  • Beams and weapons. Receivers take power only through a live, signed handshake with each beam; the Ring's tracks, like the Railheads, are open to inspection (Risks and Governance).

Reproduce these numbers

The Ring's numbers and both of its checks are in calc/src/model/ring.ts.

pnpm calc --only ring-lift                # the rotor's spare lift
pnpm calc --only ring-recovered-per-kg    # electricity per kilogram caught
pnpm calc --only lowering-support         # the least force to lower the ice
pnpm calc --set lowering-release-altitude=400000   # try dropping the ice from the Ring

The last line sets the release height to the Ring's own: the lowering check passes, the simulated Earth-like date moves past the deadline and the Lattice-only budget no longer closes. A larger Photonic Exhaust (exhaust-peak) wins the date back, but only beyond the top of the Explorer's range, so try it with --set. In the Explorer itself, lowering the water shipped (ice-mass) shrinks the lowering force in proportion, but across the whole range the check still fails.