Problem

The Problem

Venus is the planet most like Earth in size and mass, and the least like it at the surface. Making it Earth-like is not mainly a chemistry problem or a materials problem. It is an energy problem: the planet holds far more heat than it can shed on its own, and the heat has nowhere quick to go.

Every number is marked:Physics: Measured, or established physicsPrecedent: Demonstrated in the real world, citedInvented: A breakthrough the plan assumesDesign choice: A size, count or date the plan choosesSelect any number to see how it is computed.

Venus today

PropertyVenusEarth
Mass ( of Earth's)
Radius
Surface gravity ()
Atmosphere mass
Surface pressure
Composition CO₂, N₂, SO₂, traces N₂, O₂
Mean surface temperature ()
Rotation, retrograde; a solar day lasts ; a solar day lasts
Sunlight at the top of the atmosphere
WaterNearly none, with an extreme deuterium to hydrogen ratio
Magnetic fieldNone of its ownDipole of
CloudsSulfuric acid, to upWater

Two facts make the problem smaller than it looks.

  • Between and up, Venus's air already has Earth-like pressure and temperature. That is where the plan's floating machinery works.
  • Venus's nitrogen alone, , would press down with once the CO₂ is gone: times as much nitrogen as Earth has. The air Phosphoros wants is mostly there already. The job is to take the carbon dioxide out of it and the heat out of the planet.

Why ten years is impossible by conventional means

Every conventional route to an Earth-like Venus fails the same test: it needs more power than Venus receives from the Sun, or more mass than Earth can launch, or more time than a decade.

Power needs against supply, 10-year tasks, log scaleEvery conventional 10-year task needs more power than all the sunlight Venus intercepts (3.0 × 10¹⁷ W). The Helios Lattice delivers 7.0 × 10¹⁹ W.10¹²10¹³10¹⁴10¹⁵10¹⁶10¹⁷10¹⁸10¹⁹10²⁰10²¹Power in watts (log scale; each gridline is ten times the last)All the sunlightVenus interceptsWhat the HeliosLattice deliversPower there isHumanity's primary power use: 1.9 × 10¹³ WHumanity's primary power use1.9 × 10¹³ W1.9 × 10¹³ WA shaded Venus radiating at 230 K: 7.3 × 10¹⁶ WA shaded Venus radiating at 230 K7.3 × 10¹⁶ W7.3 × 10¹⁶ WAll the sunlight Venus intercepts: 3.0 × 10¹⁷ WAll the sunlight Venus intercepts3.0 × 10¹⁷ W3.0 × 10¹⁷ WHelios Lattice, the plan's supply: 7.0 × 10¹⁹ WHelios Lattice, the plan's supply7.0 × 10¹⁹ W7.0 × 10¹⁹ WPower a 10-year campaign needsCool the atmosphere: 1.7 × 10¹⁸ WCool the atmosphere1.7 × 10¹⁸ W1.7 × 10¹⁸ WCool it and shed the Bosch heat: 4.7 × 10¹⁸ WCool it and shed the Bosch heat4.7 × 10¹⁸ W4.7 × 10¹⁸ WLaunch the CO₂ to escape speed: 8.0 × 10¹⁹ WLaunch the CO₂ to escape speed8.0 × 10¹⁹ W8.0 × 10¹⁹ WSpin Venus up to an Earth day: 4.9 × 10²⁰ WSpin Venus up to an Earth day4.9 × 10²⁰ W4.9 × 10²⁰ W
Power needs against supply. Every conventional route needs more power for 10 years than all the sunlight Venus intercepts, 3.0 × 10¹⁷ W. The plan brings in 7.0 × 10¹⁹ W from the Sun at Mercury instead.View sourceSVG
The data in words

Power on a log scale. Humanity uses far less than the sunlight Venus intercepts (3.0 × 10¹⁷ W); every 10-year task needs more than that sunlight; the Helios Lattice delivers 7.0 × 10¹⁹ W.

GroupItemPower
Power there isHumanity's primary power use1.9 × 10¹³ W
Power there isA shaded Venus radiating at 230 K7.3 × 10¹⁶ W
Power there isAll the sunlight Venus intercepts3.0 × 10¹⁷ W
Power there isHelios Lattice, the plan's supply7.0 × 10¹⁹ W
Power a 10-year campaign needsCool the atmosphere1.7 × 10¹⁸ W
Power a 10-year campaign needsCool it and shed the Bosch heat4.7 × 10¹⁸ W
Power a 10-year campaign needsLaunch the CO₂ to escape speed8.0 × 10¹⁹ W
Power a 10-year campaign needsSpin Venus up to an Earth day4.9 × 10²⁰ W

The atmosphere's heat

To freeze the CO₂ out of the air, the whole atmosphere must be cooled to about . That means removing of sensible heat, plus of latent heat released as the CO₂ condenses and freezes: in all. Every route below has to get rid of this heat somehow.

The crust's heat

The rock holds even more. Cooling the top kilometer of crust by would mean removing , nearly as much as the air. But rock conducts heat slowly. In a -year campaign the cold reaches only down, and conduction delivers just to the surface. So the crust does not set the pace of a fast campaign. It does keep leaking heat into whatever sits on it for centuries, which is why the basins that hold the frozen CO₂ need refrigerated floors.

Passive cooling

Suppose a perfect sunshade cut off all sunlight. Venus would still cool only by radiating from its cloud tops at about : . At that rate the atmosphere's heat takes to leave. As the air cools toward the frost point it radiates less (), and the estimate stretches to . A shade alone gives a terraformed Venus in centuries, not a decade.

The ten-year power

Removing that heat in years takes of continuous heat rejection. That is times all the sunlight Venus intercepts (), and times humanity's entire primary power use (). Venus cannot supply this from its own sunlight even in principle. The power has to be brought in.

Launching the CO₂ to escape

Throwing the CO₂ off the planet at Venus's escape speed of takes , far more than the cooling task. Over ten years that is , times the sunlight Venus intercepts. Freezing the CO₂ in place is far cheaper than removing it.

Spinning Venus up

Venus turns once in . Spinning it up to an Earth-length day would take , times the cooling task, or for a decade. So Phosphoros makes the day with light, not rotation: the Veil opens and closes over the sunward side, and mirrors light the night side.

The Bosch route

Reacting all of Venus's of CO₂ with hydrogen (CO₂ + 2H₂ → C + 2H₂O) would make of water, an global ocean, and of graphite. It needs of hydrogen that Venus does not have, and the reaction releases of heat, more than the atmosphere holds today. Cooling in ten years would then take .

Carbonates

Locking the CO₂ into rock as carbonate needs of lime. Basalt is about lime, so that means overturning of crust across the whole planet. Left to nature, the reaction takes tens of millions of years (Bullock and Grinspoon 1996).

A sunshade launched from Earth

Even the simplest piece, a shade the size of Venus's disk made of film, has a mass of . At per heavy-lift launch (NewSpace Economy 2026) that is launches. Anything this large must be made in space, from material already there.

What follows

A decade is impossible without two things: energy imported from outside Venus, and an industry that builds in space from local material. The Sun supplies the first, if it is harvested close in, near Mercury, where sunlight is . The second needs a factory that grows itself. Phosphoros invents both, and then spends the energy where the conventional routes spend it badly: it pumps the heat out as light, freezes the CO₂ in place, and catches the imported water without letting it fall in as heat. The Plan shows how.

The literature

People have proposed terraforming Venus since 1961. Phosphoros borrows from the best of them.

ProposalMechanismVerdict
Sagan (1961) sourceSeed the clouds with algae to turn CO₂ into oxygen and organic matterLeaves tens of bars of oxygen and the carbon still in the air; not viable alone
Adelman (1982) sourceStrip the atmosphere with asteroid impactsNeeds more impactor mass than the atmosphere it removes; rejected
Birch (1991) sourceA sunshade near L1, freeze out the CO₂, bury or export it, import water from an icy moon, mirrors (solettas) for daylight, heat pipes, and a 24 h day made by the shade's orbitAbout 200 years. The backbone of every later plan, including this one
Bullock and Grinspoon (1996) sourceReact CO₂ with calcium and magnesium minerals in the crustTakes 10 to 100 million years naturally
Landis; NASA HAVOC (2011) sourceAerostat cities floating at about 50 km, where pressure and temperature are Earth-likeFeasible habitats, not a planet
Howe, Cloud Continents (2022) sourceA floating artificial surface at 50 km of about 7 × 10¹⁰ tiles 100 m across, with imported waterAbout 200 years, limited by energy
Green and colleagues (NASA) (2017) sourceA magnetic dipole at Mars's L1 point deflects the solar wind so an atmosphere can build upAdapted here as the Aegis Shield
Angel (2006) sourceA cloud of thin flyers near Earth's L1 that bend sunlight a few degrees to shade the planetA serious design for cooling Earth; light pressure barely moves a refracting shade

What Phosphoros takes from Birch 1991. Paul Birch's "Terraforming Venus Quickly" (Birch 1991) is the backbone of every serious plan since, including this one. He put a sunshade between the Sun and Venus, let the planet cool, froze out the CO₂ and buried it, brought water from an icy moon, and used the shade's own motion to give the surface a day. Phosphoros keeps that architecture almost whole: freeze and bury the CO₂, import the water, use the shade as thermostat and day clock. What it changes is the pace. Birch's planet cools by radiating on its own, which takes centuries. Phosphoros pumps the heat out with imported power, and pays for that with an industry Birch did not assume.

What Phosphoros takes from Angel 2006. Roger Angel's design for shading Earth (Angel 2006) is a cloud of thin flyers near the Sun-Earth L1 point that bend sunlight a few degrees, so it misses the planet, instead of reflecting it. A refracting film absorbs little of the light's momentum, so light pressure barely pushes it off station. Version 2 of Phosphoros moved its Veil to a hovering "statite" far closer to Venus to save area; version 3 found that a shade there cannot hover, because sunlight and Venus's gravity push it the same way, and returned to Angel's approach near L1 (correction). The Hesperus Veil is Angel's shade, scaled to Venus.

The rest of the table feeds in too. Bullock and Grinspoon's mineral chemistry becomes the Acid Sweep; the aerostat habitats of Landis and NASA's HAVOC study become the Photonic Exhaust's floating canopies; and NASA's magnetic shield for Mars becomes the Aegis Shield.