Technologies · Venus

Cryo-continents

All of Venus's CO₂ rains out as liquid, freezes, and is sealed under insulated caps: of dry ice in plateaus thick over of the planet. The caps let the sky warm to Earth-like temperatures while the ice below stays at . The plateaus become new land, and their floors need refrigerating for centuries.

Every number is marked:Physics: Measured, or established physicsPrecedent: Demonstrated in the real world, citedInvented: A breakthrough the plan assumesDesign choice: A size, count or date the plan choosesSelect any number to see how it is computed.

CO₂ phase diagram with Venus's simulated cooling pathPressure on a log scale against temperature. The path starts at Venus today, 737 K, 90 bar of CO₂, crosses the critical point, follows the vapour curve to the triple point and the frost curve to 195 K, 1 bar, then drops to 74 Pa as Frost Towers cold-trap the rest.10¹ Pa10² Pa10³ Pa10⁴ Pa10⁵ Pa10⁶ Pa10⁷ Pa10⁸ Pa150 K200 K250 K300 K350 K700 K750 KTemperature (the axis is broken between 360 K and 700 K)CO₂ pressure (log scale; each gridline is ten times the last)Sublimation curve: solid CO₂ in equilibrium with its vapourVapour curve: liquid CO₂ in equilibrium with its vapourMelting curve: solid and liquid CO₂ in equilibriumSOLIDLIQUIDGASSUPERCRITICALSealed dry ice at 180 K: 2.4 bar of air on top, 280 bar at the base of 2 kmThe base would melt at 222 Kmelts at 222 KSealed dry ice180 K, 2 km thick280 bar at the baseThe air's CO₂ partial pressure against its temperature, week by weekVenus today: 737 K, 90 bar of CO₂Venus today737 K, 90 bar of CO₂Critical point, 304 K, 73.8 barClear Rain begins19 January 2034at the critical point,304 K, 73.8 barTriple point, 216.6 K, 5.2 barSeas freeze, 14 March 2036at the triple point, 216.6 K, 5.2 barAll the CO₂ is down: 195 K, 1 barAll the CO₂ is down, 20 April 2036195 K, 1 barFrost Towers finish: 74 PaFrost Towers finish, 9 May 2036caps sealed by 30 June 2036Frost Tower cold trap: 133 K, 74 PaFrost Towers trap CO₂ at 133 Kthe frost pressure there, 74 Pa, is all the CO₂ the air keepsEarth-like, 30 September 2036: 288 K, 74 Pa of CO₂Earth-like, 30 September 2036288 K, 74 Pa of CO₂Simulated pathPhase boundaries
CO₂'s phases and the cooling path. Venus's CO₂ is supercritical today. Cooled past the critical point it rains out, follows the vapour curve to the triple point and freezes; Frost Towers at 133 K leave 74 Pa in the air, and the sealed dry ice stays solid at 180 K.View sourceSVG
The data in words

A CO₂ phase diagram, pressure on a log scale against temperature, with the sublimation, vapour and melting curves. The simulated path of the air's CO₂ runs from Venus today (737 K, 90 bar of CO₂) to Earth-like on 30 September 2036 (288 K, 74 Pa of CO₂). The sealed dry ice sits at 180 K, from 2.4 bar at its top to 280 bar at its base, where it would melt at 222 K.

PointWhenState
Venus todayBefore cooling737 K, 90 bar of CO₂
Critical point: the Clear Rain begins19 January 2034304 K, 73.8 bar
Triple point: the seas freeze14 March 2036216.6 K, 5.2 bar
All the CO₂ is down20 April 2036195 K, 1 bar
Frost Towers finish9 May 203674 Pa of CO₂ left in the air
Frost Tower cold trap133 K, 74 Pa
Earth-like30 September 2036288 K, 74 Pa of CO₂
Sealed dry iceSealed by 30 June 2036180 K, 280 bar at the base; melts there at 222 K

Principle

CO₂ has three regimes that matter here:

  • Above its critical point, and , there is no liquid at all, only gas. That is Venus today.
  • Between the critical point and the triple point, and , CO₂ can be liquid under its own vapor. Venus's air, at , is far above the triple-point pressure, so as it cools below its CO₂ condenses and rains.
  • Below the triple point it is solid. The vapor over dry ice keeps falling with temperature: at it is still , and at the Frost Towers' only .

Left open to a warm sky, dry ice turns straight back into gas. Sealed under a gas-tight, insulated lid, it is cut off from the air: the air above can sit at while the ice stays at . The insulation, not the cold, is what keeps the CO₂ out of the sky.

Design

The sequence

The dates are from the day-by-day simulation, which treats the whole atmosphere as one temperature. Real basins will run ahead of or behind these dates by place.

  1. The Clear Rain, . The air falls below and liquid CO₂ rains out. It runs downhill into the lowland basins, such as Atalanta Planitia, which the Thermal Chimneys have already filled with pooled cold air. The surface pressure starts to fall from .
  2. The seas cool, 2034 to 2036. As the Exhaust keeps pumping, the air and the seas cool together along CO₂'s vapor curve. Every kelvin lower, more CO₂ leaves the air for the seas, and the pressure keeps falling. The Graphite Forges float on these seas from .
  3. The seas freeze, . Below the seas freeze from the top down. By the air is at and all the CO₂ that will come down by cooling alone is down.
  4. Scavenging, to . The Frost Towers freeze the last of vapor out of the air, down to .
  5. Sealing, to . Crawler-rafts, waiting on the seas since before the freeze, lay the caps as the ice hardens. Each cap is a graphite membrane that stops the gas, of carbon aerogel that stops the heat, and of crushed basalt armor with soil on top. Version 2 sealed in 2035; the simulation freezes the seas only in March 2036, so sealing has the months between the freeze and the end of June.
  6. The thaw above, . With the caps sealed, the Veil opens. The thin nitrogen and oxygen air warms to by , and cap surfaces warm with it. Venus is Earth-like on , when the oxygen is complete.
The simulated atmosphere, 2033 to 2036Day-by-day simulation. The air cools from 737 K to the CO₂ frost point, then warms to 288 K; surface pressure falls to 2.4 bar. Earth-like on 30 September 2036.The air coolsThe CO₂ rains out into seas200 K300 K400 K500 K600 K700 KMean air temperatureEarth-like: 285 K or warmerEarth-like: 285 K or warmer0.0001 bar0.001 bar0.01 bar0.1 bar1 bar10 bar100 barSurface pressure (log scale; each gridline is ten times the last)TotalCO₂OxygenEarth-like: CO₂ under 600 ppm of the airEarth-like: CO₂ under 600 ppm of the airThe Clear Rain begins: 19 January 2034The CO₂ seas freeze: 14 March 2036All the CO₂ is down: 20 April 2036Frost Towers finish: 9 May 2036Caps sealed, the Veil opens: 30 June 2036Earth-like: 30 September 2036Deadline: 31 December 2036Deadline 31 December 2036Earth-like 30 September 2036Caps sealed, the Veil opens 30 June 2036Frost Towers finish 9 May 2036All the CO₂ is down 20 April 2036The CO₂ seas freeze 14 March 2036The Clear Rain begins 19 January 2034Mean air temperature: 737 K to 288 KOxygen partial pressure, rising to 0.25 barCO₂ partial pressure, falling to 310 ppm of the airSurface pressure, falling to 2.4 bar288 K737 K737 K2.4 bar0.25 bar310 ppm2033203420352036
The simulated atmosphere. The day-by-day simulation cools the air from 737 K, rains and freezes the CO₂ out, then warms the air to 288 K. It is Earth-like on 30 September 2036, before the deadline of 31 December 2036.View sourceSVG
The data in words

Temperature falls from 737 K to the CO₂ frost point and rises to 288 K; surface pressure falls to 2.4 bar, with 0.25 bar of oxygen and 310 ppm of CO₂.

EventDate
The Clear Rain begins19 January 2034
The CO₂ seas freeze14 March 2036
All the CO₂ is down20 April 2036
Frost Towers finish9 May 2036
Caps sealed, the Veil opens30 June 2036
Earth-like30 September 2036
Deadline31 December 2036

The plateaus

The CO₂ as dry ice, at , fills . At thick that covers , a third of the planet. The caps take of carbon aerogel, at , of graphite membrane and of basalt. All the carbon comes from the Forges.

Heat from above. Aerogel conducts only . Across , between a surface and ice, the leak is k ΔT / L: , over all the caps. That is the easy part.

Compartments. The caps are divided into sealed cells of , each holding at most . A breach is one cell's problem.

The floor is the hard part

The rock under the basins sat at for ages, and its heat does not leave when the air cools. Heat conducted up from hot rock into a cold floor falls off as the square root of time, q = k ΔT / √(π κ t), with basalt's conductivity and diffusivity . Taking an effective step of , smaller than the full difference because the floors are cooled before the CO₂ arrives:

Years after sealingHeat rising through the floor
2
10
100
1,000

Over the whole footprint that is at first and still after a century, far more than the leaking down through the caps. Unrefrigerated, it is enough heat to sublimate of all the CO₂ every year. Under of dry ice the base is far above the triple-point pressure, so in practice the heat would melt the base of the sheet into liquid CO₂ that could lubricate it and work its way out.

The answer is to take the heat out before it reaches the ice. Basal heat pipes are drilled into the basin floors before the Clear Rain: sodium for the hot early rock, ammonia once it cools. Insulated risers carry the heat up through the ice to radiators on the cap surface, where Exhaust tiles throw it to space. Pumping the first away, even in the worst case of lifting it from the ice's temperature to the tiles' effective , takes of the Lattice's , and less every year as the rock cools. It never stops entirely: this is a permanent duty, like pumping a polder dry.

Specifications

ParameterValue
CO₂ stored, of dry ice
Footprint, of Venus, thick
Cap graphite membrane, carbon aerogel, basalt
Cap mass of Forge graphite
Heat leaking down through the cap, in all
Heat up from the rock after 2 years, after 10, after 100, after 1,000
Floor load at first, within a century
Refrigeration of the Lattice at first
Compartments cells of , at most each

What is invented

Build sequence

  • : Cryo-seal begins: dry ice stored under a cap at Earth temperature for a year, measuring the leak. Its kill signal is a cap that cracks under thermal cycling.
  • : Active cooling begins. Basal heat pipes are drilled into the lowland basins while they are still dry.
  • : The Clear Rain. Liquid CO₂ fills the basins.
  • : The Forges start making graphite on the seas, the caps' raw material.
  • : The seas freeze from the top. Sealing begins as the ice hardens.
  • : All the CO₂ is down at .
  • : The Frost Towers finish.
  • : The last caps are sealed. By then the Forges have made of graphite, more than the the caps need (check). The Veil opens.
  • : The air over the caps is warm.
  • : Venus is Earth-like. The floor refrigeration carries on beyond the deadline, falling toward within a century.

Failure modes and safeguards

  • A torn cell. One cell holds at most of CO₂, which adds less to the air than the gap between the finished air's and the Earth-like limit of . Each cell has its own seal and its own refrigeration, and is resealed by the crawlers that laid it.
  • Refrigeration stops. The floor heat works slowly: of the CO₂ a year at first, less as the rock cools. There is time to repair, but not forever.
  • The Veil fails open. Sunlight warms the air and the cap surfaces, not the ice under of aerogel. The caps are the backstop for the Hesperus Veil, not the other way round.
  • Volcanism. Venus is volcanically active. An eruption under a cap is a local breach, contained by its cells.
  • Later choices. The CO₂ can stay forever, be turned slowly into carbonate rock, or be exported over centuries by mass drivers on the Braking Ring. None of this is needed by 2036.

Reproduce these numbers

The caps, leaks and floor heat come from calc/src/model/cryo.ts; the dates from calc/src/model/trajectory.ts.

pnpm calc --only cryo-floor-load           # k ΔT / √(π κ t) over the footprint, two years in
pnpm calc --only cryo-leak-flux            # k ΔT / L through the aerogel
pnpm calc --only cryo-refrigeration-share  # pumping the floor heat away, as a share of the Lattice
pnpm calc --only traj-freeze               # when the seas freeze, day by day

Try pnpm calc --set cryo-thickness=3000: thicker plateaus cover less of the planet and need less cap carbon, but each cell holds more CO₂, so a breach is bigger. A thinner cryo-aerogel-thickness raises the leak in proportion and saves carbon. A larger cryo-floor-step, floors less cooled before the CO₂ arrives, raises the floor load in proportion.