Technologies · Venus

Photonic Exhaust

floating canopies carry of emitter tiles, of Venus's area, that pump the planet's heat into light and fire it into space at . Each tile shines while sitting at the temperature of the air it cools. At the peak the Exhaust throws out ; over the campaign it removes of Venus's heat and spends of beamed electricity doing it.

Every number is marked:Physics: Measured, or established physicsPrecedent: Demonstrated in the real world, citedInvented: A breakthrough the plan assumesDesign choice: A size, count or date the plan choosesSelect any number to see how it is computed.

Venus's heat path, in cross-sectionAltitude to scale up to 80 km. Fans pull 737 K air through a chimney's exchangers; sealed liquid loops lift the heat to the Exhaust canopy at 65 km, which throws it to space as infrared light. The Braking Ring, 400 km up, takes the Lattice's beam and sends power down tethers. After 2036, heat pipes carry the floor heat up through the sealed dry ice.0 km10 km20 km30 km40 km50 km60 km70 km80 km400 kmAltitudes to scale up to 80 km; widths notSulfuric-acid clouds, 48 km to 70 kmHot rock under 737 K airLowland basincold air pools, then CO₂ seas, then sealed dry iceHelios Lattice beam in10 MW/m² at the receiversBraking Ring, 400 km upBraking Ringreceiver loss heat shed at 1,500 KPower down the tetherssuperconducting cables to the canopiesInfrared to space2.3 µm, in 25° cones3.0 × 10¹⁵ W per canopypasses the Veil untouchedPhotonic Exhaust canopy at 65 km, 80 km acrossExhaust canopyExhaust canopy65 km up, 80 km across65 km up, 80 km acrosstiles pump heat into lighttiles pump heat into lightThermal Chimney, 1 km to 65 km: 1.2 × 10¹⁵ W eachThermal ChimneyThermal Chimneysealed liquid loopssealed liquid loopslift the heat, stagelift the heat, stageby stage: hot legs up, cool downby stage: hot legs up, cool down1.2 × 10¹⁵ W per chimney1.2 × 10¹⁵ W per chimneyFans pull hot airFans pull hot airthrough exchangers at 20 m/sthrough exchangers at 20 m/sit leaves 300 K coolerit leaves 300 K coolercooled air drains to the basincooled air drains to the basinBasin floor, from 2036magnified, not to scaleto spaceCap: 2 m basalt, 20 maerogel, 1 mm membraneDry ice2 km thick, 180 KHeat pipes, 200 m deeplift 12 PW at first,up a riser to the cap
How Venus's heat gets out. Heat leaves the deep air through a chimney's exchangers and climbs in sealed liquid loops, because rising gas would cool by expanding; the canopy at 65 km pumps it into infrared light and throws it to space, on power the Ring sends down from 400 km. After 2036, heat pipes keep the floor heat out of the sealed dry ice.View sourceSVG
The data in words

A vertical cross-section, altitudes to scale up to 80 km. A Thermal Chimney rises from 1 km to 65 km. Fans at its base pull 737 K air through heat exchangers at 20 m/s, cooling it by 300 K; the cooled air drains into a lowland basin. Sealed liquid loops, stage by stage, lift 1.2 × 10¹⁵ W per chimney to the Exhaust canopy, 80 km across, whose tiles fire 2.3 µm light into 25° cones, 3.0 × 10¹⁵ W per canopy. The clouds lie between 48 km and 70 km. The Braking Ring at 400 km takes the Lattice's beam at 10 MW/m², sheds its receiver loss heat at 1,500 K, and sends power down tethers to the canopies. In the basin, after 2036, dry ice 2 km thick at 180 K lies under a cap of 2 m of basalt, 20 m of aerogel and a 1 mm membrane; heat pipes 200 m into the floor carry 12 PW at first up a riser to radiators on the cap.

ElementWhereWhat it does
Thermal Chimney1 km to 65 kmlifts 1.2 × 10¹⁵ W in sealed liquid loops
Intake fans and exchangersfrom 1 kmcool 737 K air by 300 K
Exhaust canopy65 kmthrows 3.0 × 10¹⁵ W to space at 2.3 µm
Clouds48 km to 70 kmsulfuric acid
Braking Ring400 kmtakes the Lattice beam at 10 MW/m²; power down tethers
Basal heat pipes200 m into the basin floorcarry 12 PW at first

Principle

A radiator is not enough. Anything radiates at most σT⁴ at its own temperature. Venus, shaded, radiates from its cloud tops at about , in all, a few hundred watts per square meter. At that rate cooling would take . To finish in a few years, heat has to leave far faster than any surface at the air's temperature can shine. It has to be pumped.

A light-emitting heat pump. An LED makes about one photon per electron. The photon's energy is set by the semiconductor's bandgap; the electron's energy is set by the voltage. Drive the diode just below its bandgap and each photon leaves with more energy than its electron brought. The difference is taken from the vibrations of the crystal, which is to say from heat: the LED cools while it shines. MIT showed it, an LED emitting of light from of electricity (Santhanam 2012). The Exhaust's tiles must do the same at a power density that has never been approached, with a bandgap of , which sets the wavelength.

LED light is not heat radiation, so it is not limited by σT⁴. The voltage packs photons into the diode's band far more densely than a thermal body at the tile's temperature would. That lets a tile at a few hundred kelvin shine , what a black body at radiates.

The Carnot cost. Nothing escapes the second law. A heat pump moving heat dQ from a cold side at T_c into a hot reservoir at T_h needs at least dW = dQ (T_h / T_c − 1) of work. Here the cold side is the air, and the hot reservoir is the light itself; the model takes its temperature as the emitters' effective . Summed along the cooling path, from down to :

  • the sensible cooling costs of work;
  • the latent heat, released as the CO₂ condenses and freezes between and , costs , more than the sensible part because it comes out when the air is cold and every joule is dearest;
  • in all, for of heat: joules of electricity per joule moved.

Heat and work both leave as light, in all. The model checks that the pumps never beat Carnot (check). It charges exactly the Carnot work, the least the second law allows; real tiles will need more.

The trade. The effective temperature is a choice. Hotter light means brighter tiles and less area, but more work per joule. Run the same campaign with the coolest emitters the model tries and the working emitters would cover of Venus; with the middle option, ; with the hottest, , for more work. The ledger gives each option's temperature. The plan picks .

Against a shaded Venus radiating alone, the Exhaust throws out times as much light on average, and removes times as much of the planet's own heat. The difference between the two is the work.

Design

Canopies. Each canopy is a hexagonal aerostat across, , floating at the top of its Thermal Chimney, up. It floats on CO₂ warmed by the heat arriving from below, a hot-air balloon heated by the heat it is pumping out. Exchangers in its floor take heat from the chimney's liquid loops; tiles on its top throw it to space. As the CO₂ rains out and the air thins, the canopies float lower. On average each one takes in of electricity and throws out of light.

Tiles. Each tile is an InGaAsSb thermophotonic diode with a bandgap. A photon-recycling cavity sends light that would be reabsorbed back for another chance to escape. Every electron that recombines without making a photon dumps its energy into the tile as heat, so the tiles must reach an external quantum efficiency of . A photonic-crystal face aims the light upward into a cone.

Why . The thin CO₂ above the canopies barely absorbs at that wavelength, and the Hesperus Veil is made transparent there, so the beams leave Venus and pass the Veil untouched.

Sizing, and why version 3 made it bigger. Version 2 sized the Exhaust from the campaign's average, , which of working tiles can shine. The day-by-day simulation shows that the average hides three different phases:

  1. January to June 2033. The Lattice is still growing and all of it goes to cooling. Cooling is fast.
  2. June 2033 to August 2034. The Ceres Railheads draw of the Lattice's . Cooling crawls; the Clear Rain begins on .
  3. From August 2034. The Ring recovers from the arriving ice and powers the Railheads. Power is now plentiful, and the emitters, not the supply, set the pace.

So the emitters must be sized for the peak of the third phase. With version 2's smaller Exhaust the simulated air becomes Earth-like months after the deadline. With of emitters, , the CO₂ is down by and the air is Earth-like on , with to spare. A bigger Exhaust buys nothing: the finish then waits on the Forges' oxygen, and the extra pumping overdraws the Lattice.

The simulated atmosphere, 2033 to 2036Day-by-day simulation. The air cools from 737 K to the CO₂ frost point, then warms to 288 K; surface pressure falls to 2.4 bar. Earth-like on 30 September 2036.The air coolsThe CO₂ rains out into seas200 K300 K400 K500 K600 K700 KMean air temperatureEarth-like: 285 K or warmerEarth-like: 285 K or warmer0.0001 bar0.001 bar0.01 bar0.1 bar1 bar10 bar100 barSurface pressure (log scale; each gridline is ten times the last)TotalCO₂OxygenEarth-like: CO₂ under 600 ppm of the airEarth-like: CO₂ under 600 ppm of the airThe Clear Rain begins: 19 January 2034The CO₂ seas freeze: 14 March 2036All the CO₂ is down: 20 April 2036Frost Towers finish: 9 May 2036Caps sealed, the Veil opens: 30 June 2036Earth-like: 30 September 2036Deadline: 31 December 2036Deadline 31 December 2036Earth-like 30 September 2036Caps sealed, the Veil opens 30 June 2036Frost Towers finish 9 May 2036All the CO₂ is down 20 April 2036The CO₂ seas freeze 14 March 2036The Clear Rain begins 19 January 2034Mean air temperature: 737 K to 288 KOxygen partial pressure, rising to 0.25 barCO₂ partial pressure, falling to 310 ppm of the airSurface pressure, falling to 2.4 bar288 K737 K737 K2.4 bar0.25 bar310 ppm2033203420352036
The simulated atmosphere. The day-by-day simulation cools the air from 737 K, rains and freezes the CO₂ out, then warms the air to 288 K. It is Earth-like on 30 September 2036, before the deadline of 31 December 2036.View sourceSVG
The data in words

Temperature falls from 737 K to the CO₂ frost point and rises to 288 K; surface pressure falls to 2.4 bar, with 0.25 bar of oxygen and 310 ppm of CO₂.

EventDate
The Clear Rain begins19 January 2034
The CO₂ seas freeze14 March 2036
All the CO₂ is down20 April 2036
Frost Towers finish9 May 2036
Caps sealed, the Veil opens30 June 2036
Earth-like30 September 2036
Deadline31 December 2036

What the simulation pumps. The simulation spends of pump work, more than the the air alone needs. Heat keeps arriving from the crust, the Forges' waste, the falling ice and the sunlight the closed Veil lets through, in all, much of it late, when pumping is dearest. With everything else, the plan's demand is against the Lattice's : to spare from the Lattice alone, once the Ring powers the Railheads.

Frost Towers. At the air still holds of CO₂ vapor, . The same tiles on surface towers held at freeze it out down to , leaving airborne and in the finished air. That takes of work and is done by .

CO₂ phase diagram with Venus's simulated cooling pathPressure on a log scale against temperature. The path starts at Venus today, 737 K, 90 bar of CO₂, crosses the critical point, follows the vapour curve to the triple point and the frost curve to 195 K, 1 bar, then drops to 74 Pa as Frost Towers cold-trap the rest.10¹ Pa10² Pa10³ Pa10⁴ Pa10⁵ Pa10⁶ Pa10⁷ Pa10⁸ Pa150 K200 K250 K300 K350 K700 K750 KTemperature (the axis is broken between 360 K and 700 K)CO₂ pressure (log scale; each gridline is ten times the last)Sublimation curve: solid CO₂ in equilibrium with its vapourVapour curve: liquid CO₂ in equilibrium with its vapourMelting curve: solid and liquid CO₂ in equilibriumSOLIDLIQUIDGASSUPERCRITICALSealed dry ice at 180 K: 2.4 bar of air on top, 280 bar at the base of 2 kmThe base would melt at 222 Kmelts at 222 KSealed dry ice180 K, 2 km thick280 bar at the baseThe air's CO₂ partial pressure against its temperature, week by weekVenus today: 737 K, 90 bar of CO₂Venus today737 K, 90 bar of CO₂Critical point, 304 K, 73.8 barClear Rain begins19 January 2034at the critical point,304 K, 73.8 barTriple point, 216.6 K, 5.2 barSeas freeze, 14 March 2036at the triple point, 216.6 K, 5.2 barAll the CO₂ is down: 195 K, 1 barAll the CO₂ is down, 20 April 2036195 K, 1 barFrost Towers finish: 74 PaFrost Towers finish, 9 May 2036caps sealed by 30 June 2036Frost Tower cold trap: 133 K, 74 PaFrost Towers trap CO₂ at 133 Kthe frost pressure there, 74 Pa, is all the CO₂ the air keepsEarth-like, 30 September 2036: 288 K, 74 Pa of CO₂Earth-like, 30 September 2036288 K, 74 Pa of CO₂Simulated pathPhase boundaries
CO₂'s phases and the cooling path. Venus's CO₂ is supercritical today. Cooled past the critical point it rains out, follows the vapour curve to the triple point and freezes; Frost Towers at 133 K leave 74 Pa in the air, and the sealed dry ice stays solid at 180 K.View sourceSVG
The data in words

A CO₂ phase diagram, pressure on a log scale against temperature, with the sublimation, vapour and melting curves. The simulated path of the air's CO₂ runs from Venus today (737 K, 90 bar of CO₂) to Earth-like on 30 September 2036 (288 K, 74 Pa of CO₂). The sealed dry ice sits at 180 K, from 2.4 bar at its top to 280 bar at its base, where it would melt at 222 K.

PointWhenState
Venus todayBefore cooling737 K, 90 bar of CO₂
Critical point: the Clear Rain begins19 January 2034304 K, 73.8 bar
Triple point: the seas freeze14 March 2036216.6 K, 5.2 bar
All the CO₂ is down20 April 2036195 K, 1 bar
Frost Towers finish9 May 203674 Pa of CO₂ left in the air
Frost Tower cold trap133 K, 74 Pa
Earth-like30 September 2036288 K, 74 Pa of CO₂
Sealed dry iceSealed by 30 June 2036180 K, 280 bar at the base; melts there at 222 K

Specifications

ParameterValue
Canopies, each about across
Emitter area working at the average, installed for the peak
Emission at , in a cone
Effective emitter temperature
Heat removed from Venus's air (average )
Pump work for that heat, J per joule moved
Pump work in the simulation, counting heat from the crust, the Forges and the ice
Peak power out
Per canopy in, out
Frost TowersTiles at trap the last CO₂ to

What is invented

Build sequence

  • : Exhaust-1 begins in the laboratory. Its kill signal, no net cooling at useful power, would send the plan back to the multi-century route.
  • : Exhaust-1 must have passed.
  • : Under the closed Veil, the canopies float up and their chimneys are lowered.
  • : Active cooling begins, on the growing Lattice's power.
  • : The Railheads take most of the power; cooling slows.
  • : The Clear Rain: liquid CO₂ starts to fall.
  • : The Ring pays for the Railheads. The Exhaust runs at its limit from here on.
  • : The CO₂ seas start to freeze.
  • : All the CO₂ is down. The Frost Towers take over.
  • : The CO₂ left in the air is at its target.
  • : Active cooling ends; the caps are sealed and the Veil opens.
  • : Venus is Earth-like.

Failure modes and safeguards

  • Dead tiles. A failed tile goes dark and its neighbors take its share. Installed area, , is well above the working on average.
  • The Ring overhead. The Braking Ring circles up. Tiles whose cones would cross it stay dark.
  • Stray light. Each canopy's light spreads through its cone. Long before it reaches the Veil it is far fainter than sunlight, and the Veil is transparent to it anyway.
  • A stalled Exhaust. Under the closed Veil, Venus gains heat only slowly, from the crust and the little sunlight the Veil lets through, so a pause costs time, not ground.
  • The second law. The model charges ideal pumping. Every real loss, and the entropy of narrow, beamed light, adds work, and from the Lattice alone the budget has only to spare. The Ring's recovered energy is the real margin.

Reproduce these numbers

The Exhaust's numbers come from calc/src/model/exhaust.ts; the day-by-day cooling from calc/src/model/trajectory.ts.

pnpm calc --only exhaust-work-ratio      # Carnot work along the cooling path, per joule moved
pnpm calc --only exhaust-area-installed  # peak power / σT⁴
pnpm calc --only traj-earth-like         # the day-by-day simulation's finish
pnpm calc --only traj-pump-energy        # what the simulation actually spends

In the Explorer, lower exhaust-peak toward version 2's size and the simulated finish slips past the deadline. Raise it and the finish does not move, because the oxygen sets it, while the pump work and the energy demand rise until the Lattice alone no longer covers them. Lower exhaust-effective-temp and each joule costs less work but the emitter area grows steeply; raise it and the area shrinks but the work grows.